BY DR. KENNY CAMACHO / SERMON DELIVERED 12 MAY 2024 FOR REVOLUTION CHURCH
Today, we are wrapping up the second of three series this year on some of our values here at Revolution. Our topic this time out has been Diversity, and the big idea is that diversity is the fruit that grows on the tree of humility. If we look around ourselves and we don’t see that fruit–if we find ourselves surrounded exclusively by people who look like us, speak like us, vote likes us, live like us, believe like us–it’s because we are struggling, on a fundamental level, to recognize that we are part of a story that is bigger than us. You guys have been pretty open to this idea the last few weeks, and I know it’s actually been challenging some of you in exciting ways.
But what we haven’t addressed so far in this series–at least, not in a thorough way–is what diversity does: If we get the humility part right, if we actually find ourselves surrounded by the actual, valuable presence of a full variety of human people, cultures, convictions, and gifts… how does it really help?
It’s an important question, and I want you to know that, this past week, our Discipleship Lay Leader Dante Griffin and I actually went searching for some answers. On Monday morning, we flew out to Austin, Texas to join our very own Andy Hanauer at a summit his organization, the One America Movement, puts on each year. One America is a non-profit whose mission statement is, unbelievably, “to build a united American society.” So, pray for Andy! The way this summit works is that One America gathers faith leaders from different religions from across the country together in one place and challenges them to sit together, listen to each other, and talk. The goal (quite explicitly) isn’t conversion: the goal is to model humility towards each other in a way that can bear witness to real and mutual love.
One of my favorite things about the conference was that it wasn’t a blended-faith event. We weren’t there to mute or restrain our separate convictions about God, about sin, about hope. When the speakers prayed before each meal, they did it in the ways that are true for them. No one “watered things down” so others might be comfortable. Instead, they explained why they do things the way they do them, and invited us to listen.
And here’s what I think that kind of work can do: it doesn’t make a “melting pot,” it makes us productively uncomfortable. When I hear a rabbi talk about God, it exposes me to new data that can both stretch and clarify the edges of what I think. When I listen to an imam read scripture, I can ask, “what is the beating heart of what he believes?”… and then that question can make its way into me, too: “what is the beating heart of what I believe?” It’s a healthy place to be, but here’s the thing: it’s also not one I ever tend to create for myself.
My favorite workshop at the conference was about AI Disinformation and Politics. I say “favorite,” but that’s not quite true–it drove me crazy. Here’s why: the speakers wanted to coach us on how we, as pastors, can help you, as congregants, stop sharing nonsense on Facebook. In many ways, I’m on board with this, so let’s try it…
KNOCK IT OFF!
… did that work? Okay, they actually had better ideas than that. But what bothered me more than the hard work we need to do to interrupt the speed with which you share disinformation is my curiosity about why the algorithms sent that disinformation to you in the first place. What have you already communicated about your beliefs that makes Facebook think you will like this meme, or this insult? Because here’s the thing about falling down rabbit holes on the Internet: nobody falls down a hole because they’re wandering around, exploring new things, getting tempted by some forbidden fruit. You fall down a hole because you love where you’re standing so much you start digging. The internet isn’t “leading” you, it’s “limiting” you.
Do any of you use Spotify? If you do, you have experienced exactly what I’m talking about: I listened to some sad songs one day when I was feeling gloomy, and now “Kenny’s Monday Mopey Mix” is constantly at the top of my feed. Spotify seems like it’s giving me more, but it’s actually giving me more examples of less: I’m hearing less new music, less new genres, less… everything!… because what it wants to do is zero in on me.
My hypothesis is this: if we don’t resist it, the world is all too happy to make sure we never run into something we don’t already like or agree with ever again… with the exception of when it occasionally shows us something so foreign the point is just to make us angry and get us to hole up even more! So, if the problem is a world that reduces the kinds of frictions which can actually clarify and strengthen what we believe… a world that doesn’t want us to encounter diversity… what can we do?
Our central Biblical text this morning comes from Paul’s letter to the Galatians. In this letter, Paul tells the story of his conversion from a life as a staunch Pharisee to a life as a Christian missionary to the Gentiles. The power of Paul’s story has always been in this radical change: before meeting Jesus, Paul would have been mortified to be in the intimate presence of non-Jews. The Pharisee tradition was Paul’s version of Spotify: it constantly narrowed down his understanding of holiness in a way that made him not only self-righteous, but unnaturally content in that self-righteousness. No friction; just endless reassurances that he was right.
But Jesus turned Paul’s life upside down, and by the time he writes this letter, his entire life is spent with folks he used to believe were unclean. And did this “tone down” Paul’s zeal for holiness? Not in the slightest! What it actually did was clarify for Paul that the holiness of God cleans the hearts of those who are obedient to him, and thus if “cleanliness” is what you long for, you have an infinitely better chance of finding it by listening to God than you do by trying to impress Him.
In any case, in this story, Paul is serving a Gentile congregation in the city of Antioch, and Jesus’s disciple Peter–who is also a central Christian leader–comes to visit. At first, Paul says that Peter followed his lead and ate his meals with the Gentiles… even though, under Jewish law, this made him ceremonially unclean. But then James and some other leaders from Jerusalem came to visit, and Peter
drew back and kept himself separate [from the gentiles] for fear of the circumcision faction. And the other Jews joined him in this hypocrisy, so that even Barnabas was led astray […] But when I saw that they were not acting consistently with the truth of the gospel, I said to [Peter] before them all, “If you, though a Jew, live like a gentile and not like a Jew, how can you compel the gentiles to live like Jews?” (Galatians 2:12-14)
Paul calls Peter out for seeking old comfort over new challenges, and he ties that behavior to the realities of ministry: “don’t you realize that the gentiles are doing something uncomfortable, too?” Paul goes on to say,
We ourselves are Jews by birth and not gentile sinners, yet we know that a person is justified not by the works of the law but through the faith of Jesus Christ. […] But if I build up again the very things that I once tore down, then I demonstrate that I am a transgressor. For through the law I died to the law, so that I might live to God. I have been crucified with Christ, and it is no longer I who live, but it is Christ who lives in me. And the life I now live in the flesh I live by the faith of the Son of God, who loved me and gave himself for me. I do not nullify the grace of God, for if righteousness comes through the law, then Christ died for nothing. (Galatians 2:15, 18-21)
There are two incredibly important things I think we can find here. The first is that we need to “sit down with the gentiles” because it’s only by encountering uncomfortable situations that the things we believe in theory can really get tested. Paul knows that Peter knows they are “justified by faith” and not by works… but he says that if your works don’t reflect your faith, they are empty. Earlier in this chapter, Paul points out that Peter is one of the leaders who had cleared the way for gentiles to be included in the Christian community as equals. But Peter had made that decision from the safe distance of Jerusalem, and in a sense, he was saying, “this is a good thing for Paul to do… but that doesn’t mean we all have to.” When he first got to Antioch, he gave it a try! But when the others arrived, he stepped back from the challenge.
In our own lives, we need to choose diversity, even when it becomes uncomfortable, precisely because it has become uncomfortable. That discomfort is hard, but without it, what is a good idea “in theory” remains only that. When Paul says he has been “crucified with Christ,” he means that he has resolved to subject what he believes about God to the utmost hardship and difficulty because if the hard path isn’t necessary, Jesus wouldn’t have needed to walk it first.
So, what does diversity “do” for us? It enables us to actually test what we believe! Is love, is grace, is compassion how our beliefs about God will flourish? Or is it just stuff somebody else can do if they want to… but it’s also okay for us to hang back and just believe the right things in our heads? If you don’t “sit down with the gentiles,” the truth is that you won’t actually know.
The second thing we see here is how important it is, how essential it is, to know a Paul. Peter’s challenge was putting his beliefs about inclusion to the actual test of sharing a meal with people he thought were unclean. But Paul’s challenge was to rebuke not just anyone, but freaking PETER! So, why does he do it? I think it’s because, most of all, he loves him. There’s an old saying I like: “the opposite of love isn’t hate, it’s indifference.” It would have been incredibly easy for Paul to just let this slide… or, even worse, to wait until Peter left and then criticize him to the gentiles! But the power of diversity–of beliefs, of convictions–is in its ability to clarify and deepen our understanding. If Paul really loves Peter, challenging him is part of that love. And if Peter really trusts Paul’s love for him, receiving that challenge is an extension of his own commitment to listening, and to growth. We need “Pauls” to push on us! But that push doesn’t work if we don’t have a relationship in place we trust will endure.
Getting our posture right–cultivating humility in our hearts–will get us in a room with people who are different. This is counter-cultural, especially in this moment of polarization and flag-planting. But once we are in that room, there is work to do! We still have to be willing to be challenged and refined there. We can put our beliefs into action… and we can listen when we come up short. We can “sit with the gentiles”… and we can “receive rebuke from the Pauls.” None of this is comfortable… but it is healthy. Both the “gentiles” and the “Pauls” in this story are folks we won’t naturally pursue on our own! But both are necessary in our circles if we hope to grow.
This year, our theme is Together on Purpose. We haven’t addressed that much in this series, but I want to rectify that today before we close. Do you want to know why I think God insists on the local church as a “good idea” for building His Kingdom? Because it’s a really wild plan, if you think about it: somehow, a million little Christian communities is going to be feel more unified than a single, big one? Somehow, grouping us together by geography is going to lead to more mutual love than letting us group up by age, by life stage, by hobbies, by politics? It’s a weird system! But my suspicion is that God chooses it because it makes darn well sure that no one can faithfully pursue him without running into discomfort. If you spend a lifetime in the church, you’re going to fight with someone eventually. You’re going to end up somewhere where you’re the only young person in the room… or the only old person in the room. Where you hate the songs on Sundays or love the songs on Sundays. Where you like the sermons or don’t like the sermons. And, on an essential level, if you really want to be faithful to the Savior who has seen to your adoption among his people, you’re going to realize you’re stuck with someone you don’t like.
At least in this culture, this might be one of the most radical things about real Christian faith: it challenges you to be comfortable with discomfort. Jesus certainly was! And when we lean in to that discomfort, when we even start to value it, we begin looking a bit more like him. The point for you, just like the point for Jesus!, isn’t to be a reed constantly blowing in the wind. You don’t have to give up what you believe every time you talk to someone new, just like Jesus never ultimately abandoned his faith. But leaning into discomfort develops what you believe, refines what you believe, sands off the parts that aren’t wholly in line with God’s heart, and fills in the gaps our own pride or fear create. You don’t get those nudges, those challenges, if you don’t make a point of being in hard spaces and relationships. Ask anyone who has been intimate and close to another person for a minimum of 10 years: has your friend, partner, or spouse “worn” on you?? And are you better for it?
We are together, on purpose: if you look around your life and you don’t see diversity, you don’t have to feel guilty, you can get excited! Maybe the algorithms have their hold on you right now, but you can break free of them–you can delete your apps, talk to a new coworker, chat with someone out on their porch–and look what’s waiting for you when you do! Listening to someone who disagrees with your politics, your parenting, your faith isn’t a threat, it’s a chance to develop and mature your thinking. Maybe some things you believe will change down the line, but that’s not a loss for you, it’s a gain! So, seek diversity because it’s how we grow… and in a moment where growth is resisted so ferociously in our culture… diversity is also how we witness to the beauty, and the difference, of God’s Kingdom.
This church needs folks from across the political spectrum in it: we won’t grow without challenge. It needs folks who pray differently, worship differently, have different understandings of what the Bible is and how it works: the point isn’t that every person’s view is already “correct,” it’s that listening to other views can help all of us have increasingly better ones. If you’re perfectly comfortable here, your faith will die here; that’s just the truth. But there is a difference between feeling uncomfortable and feeling unsafe. The world right now doesn’t believe this–safety and comfort are increasingly treated like synonyms–but we are called to believe it. The people in this room have been drawn here by the God of the Universe to help each other. We’re not a melting pot. We’re not a monoculture. We are lovingly diverse, and we can long to be increasingly diverse, because that diversity changes us.
The key difference between God’s Kingdom and the American Kingdom right now is that whereas America wants to convince you that the only way to happiness is to seek yourself endlessly–in apps, in products, in politics, in culture–we have been invited to believe that the actual way to happiness is to seek Jesus first. This is “ground zero” for diversity: we believe someone else knows more about us, more about what we need, than we do! And where does Jesus lead us? Not into self-righteousness, not into isolation, or “down a rabbit hole” of narrow and judgmental faith… but into sincere, love-filled, and challenging relationships. Diversity refines and matures us.
So, sit with Gentiles. In the right season, be a Paul. And in every other season, listen to the Pauls who challenge you. The best version of our community will be one where love triumphs over differences, not by reducing them or ignoring them, but by including them under one banner where growth isn’t something we sit back and hope for, it’s something we work for.
I’m so grateful we’re not all the same. May our differences help and not hinder us in the season ahead.